14 Comments
User's avatar
Robert C Culwell's avatar

Great work Joel,

Semper Fortis!

Tao Of Freedom's avatar

Awesome comparison ... the Rapper and the Rolling Stone!

Richard Smith's avatar

Joel, Interesting comparision . It seems the U.S. like N.Y.C. just throws money against the wall in hopes the problem gets solved, and the Policitians get elected again. Verses Pres.Melei choses to put more money in the pockets of the working class, and allows the problems to solve themselves, which they seem to do.

Tao Of Freedom's avatar

Milei is incrementally moving Argentina towards Hayekian spontaneous order ... 😉

rKf's avatar

It’s a beautiful thing: those who aren’t confused by the facts can stroll along humming a happy tune. 🎼😎

Maury Teitelbaum's avatar

Joel, What if it's The Ayatollahs' plan to depopulate the city to get ready for the 4th crusade. I think that is the Muslim plan, to get rid of the infidels so they can convert or kill everyone in the world. Hell it just might work with the millions of sheeple running around.

50 Bravo's avatar

Don’t forget that Detroit was too big to fail. When the merde finally gets into the mixer those who enabled the financial collapse of NYC will be shocked, shocked I tell you. Socialists aren’t interested in results and feedback, just guilt avoidance and “intentions”.

Tao Of Freedom's avatar

A good article Joel ... 😊

NYC is a dangerous city ... Judging by the TV crimes series ... 4 homicides/100k ...

Buenos Aires is even more dangerous at 5, but not as bad as Naples where Maradona is the Patron Saint at 7 ... that successful female author, Ferrante or something with her novels about Naples, the most dangerous city in Italy, has lots to draw upon ...

Then we have Cape Town, the most dangerous city in Africa at about 70 killings per 100k, but the government denies that and says it is only about thirty five ... the other half is malicious propaganda ...

See you in Buenos Aires ... !!! 😉

Tlasso's avatar

You got that backwards. Argentina 4 NYC 5 per 100k

Tao Of Freedom's avatar

Tx for the correction 👍... Buenos Aires even more so then ... And Naples too despite Elena Ferrante ... 😉

Bill Campbell's avatar

As always, great observations and commentary, Joel. All tweaked with a wee bit o' sarcasm. Perfect. I would like to take exception to your subtitle for this missive, "...a tale of two leaders". Sr Milei has proven his leadership capabilities, unquestionably. To refer to Mamdani as a leader (of any sort), however, is blasphemous. That lame POS is no leader. Never was. Never gonna be. The Office of the Mayor may be the defacto leader of the city, but that does not make the scum inhabiting that office any more a leader than the guy cleaning up after the parade.

Greene Financial Advisory's avatar

Having lived in and around New York for years, I remember when it truly felt like the financial center of the world—high-functioning, opportunity-rich, and aligned with the people building inside it.

What’s striking now isn’t just the policy shift, but the change in incentives. When capital, talent, and yes—billionaires—start to leave, it’s usually not about politics…it’s about cost.

Argentina is trying to relearn that lesson the hard way. New York risks forgetting it.

History doesn’t lie—the real question is whether a system still rewards those who build within it.

Sue Seboda's avatar

Thanks Joel. Actual data has a way of revealing the truth.

User's avatar
Comment removed
May 13
Comment removed
Tlasso's avatar

Are you kidding me???? ... "no doubt Mandi would like to apply similar reforms in NYC but what chance do you think he has ?" Did you ever listen to him? that is the last thing he wants. He wants power just like all communists. He wants to sit in the big house and not be of want while all his minions beg for their social due. And the wealth redistribution will destroy the City as all the people of wealth will leave rather than pay what they (in most cases} earned. Socialism has never worked for the betterment of society. What needs to happen is the Federal government should reduce or eliminate all the freebies and reimbursements to NYC and then let them fend for themselves with the exception of the truly needy and disabled and maybe the elderly. Just think if you went back to the founding of this great country. If you didn't work you didn't survive. I am all for helping the truly disabled and handicapped who have physical and mental issues but we have gotten so compassionate to help anyone who will vote for the giver's party. Unfortunately all about power. Senor Milei isn't I believe.